As a dedicated food enthusiast constantly in search of New York’s finest burger spots, I recently found myself captivated by the buzz surrounding a local SoHo gem: Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer. Nestled in the heart of SoHo, Black Tap is a burger lover’s paradise and is often touted as one of the best places for gourmet burgers in New York City. With its vibrant atmosphere, inventive menu, and a cult following for its larger-than-life shakes, Black Tap has carved out a unique spot in NYC’s competitive dining landscape. So, if you’re looking for the best burger in SoHo at Black Tap, let’s dive into what makes this place a must-visit for locals and tourists alike.
A SoHo Staple for Burger Lovers
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has a prime location at 529 Broome Street in SoHo. The atmosphere is inviting and energetic, with walls adorned with graffiti-style art that brings a cool, urban feel to the dining space. Imagine a classic American diner meets NYC’s modern artistic flair – that’s Black Tap. The setting is perfect for everything from casual lunches to late-night gatherings, and it’s not unusual to find a line of eager customers waiting to experience what Black Tap has to offer.
The menu here is all about comfort food with a twist. At its core, Black Tap is known for taking the American burger to new heights, bringing in flavors and ingredients that reflect both tradition and creativity. Each burger is thoughtfully crafted, balancing flavors and textures to ensure every bite is just right. And for those who enjoy pairing their meal with a drink, Black Tap’s extensive craft beer selection offers the perfect complement to its bold, hearty burgers.
The Burger Selection: Classic Meets Innovation
One of Black Tap’s greatest strengths lies in its burger menu. The restaurant offers a variety of options that cater to both traditionalists and those seeking something out of the ordinary.
The All-American Burger is a staple. Featuring a juicy beef patty, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and Black Tap’s signature special sauce, this burger is a go-to for purists. Each ingredient is meticulously selected, from the freshly baked buns to the top-grade beef that makes up the patty. One bite, and you’ll understand why people rave about it – it’s a classic done exceptionally well.
For those looking to indulge in something extraordinary, the Greg Norman Burger is a must-try. This award-winning creation takes things to the next level with a half-pound wagyu beef patty, blue cheese, and arugula, all perfectly nestled between a soft potato bun. The richness of the wagyu beef, combined with the bold flavor of the blue cheese, creates a mouthwatering combination that’s as decadent as it is delicious. The Greg Norman Burger is a standout item that has won acclaim not just from diners but also from critics and food awards alike.
Vegetarians and those seeking a lighter option aren’t left out, either. The Falafel Burger is a creative vegetarian option featuring a spiced chickpea patty topped with fresh cucumber, pickled onions, and a tangy tzatziki sauce. Even non-vegetarians will find themselves drawn to this flavor-packed burger, proving that Black Tap’s expertise extends beyond traditional beef patties.
Beyond Burgers: Chicken Sandwiches, Wings, and More
While burgers are the centerpiece at Black Tap, the menu also includes a variety of other offerings. The Crispy Chicken Sandwich is a fan favorite, featuring fried chicken breast topped with buttermilk coleslaw, tangy Korean BBQ sauce, and spicy mayo. The flavors here are bold and satisfying, making it an ideal option for anyone looking to try something a bit different.
Chicken wings are another must-try item. Served with your choice of sauces, from classic buffalo to a zesty Asian-inspired flavor, these wings are perfect for sharing with friends over a round of craft beers. Black Tap’s fries, served in heaping portions, come with options like sweet potato fries and truffle cheese fries, rounding out the menu with sides that can stand on their own.
The Legendary CrazyShakes®
No visit to Black Tap would be complete without one of their iconic CrazyShakes®. These milkshakes have gained a cult following, and for a good reason. They’re as much a visual treat as they are a culinary one. The shakes come loaded with toppings that range from classic whipped cream to candy bars, cotton candy, and even entire slices of cake.
One of the standout options is the Cotton Candy Shake, which arrives adorned with a cloud of cotton candy, lollipops, and rock candy. For chocolate lovers, the Sweet n Salty Shake features a chocolate frosted rim covered with M&M’s, peanut butter cups, and caramel drizzle. These shakes are over-the-top, Instagram-worthy creations that add an element of fun and indulgence to the Black Tap experience.
Craft Beers & Cocktails: A Perfect Pairing
Alongside their impressive food menu, Black Tap offers a carefully curated selection of craft beers and cocktails. Beer enthusiasts will appreciate the variety, with a mix of local brews and international options on tap. Whether you’re in the mood for a light, crisp lager or a rich, hoppy IPA, you’ll find something to pair perfectly with your meal. The cocktails, meanwhile, range from classics to inventive creations that feature seasonal ingredients and unique flavor combinations.
For those looking to keep things non-alcoholic, Black Tap also offers refreshing house-made sodas and lemonades, which are particularly welcome during New York’s warmer months.
Customer Experience and Service
Beyond the food, Black Tap is known for its welcoming and friendly atmosphere. The staff are attentive and knowledgeable, happy to make recommendations based on individual preferences. It’s clear that customer satisfaction is a priority here, as the restaurant provides multiple dining options, including takeout, delivery, and outdoor seating for those who prefer to enjoy their meal al fresco.
Recognition and Accolades
Black Tap’s commitment to quality and creativity hasn’t gone unnoticed. The restaurant has received numerous accolades over the years, including praise from Zagat, Time Out, and other renowned publications. The Greg Norman Burger, in particular, has been highlighted in multiple reviews and has won awards, making it one of the most sought-after burgers in the city. Black Tap’s success and reputation are a testament to its dedication to delivering an outstanding dining experience.
Final Thoughts: The Best Burger in SoHo Awaits
In the heart of SoHo, where culinary competition is fierce, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer stands out as a beacon for burger enthusiasts. From its expertly crafted burgers to its imaginative milkshakes and vibrant atmosphere, Black Tap offers a dining experience that’s both satisfying and memorable. Whether you’re a local or visiting New York City, a trip to Black Tap is a must if you’re in search of the best burger in SoHo.
With its combination of quality, creativity, and customer-focused service, Black Tap has more than earned its place as one of NYC’s premier burger spots. So, the next time you find yourself in SoHo with a craving for something delicious, make your way to Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer – you won’t be disappointed.
